Jimmys Pizza Cafe

Name: Jimmys Pizza Cafe
Address: 2434 w montrose Avenue, Chicago, IL, 60618, US
Telephone: +17732936992
Price range: $$
Rating: 4.5

Home
Irving Park
W Montrose Avenue
Jimmys Pizza Cafe

Located on W Montrose Avenue, Jimmys Pizza Cafe is a popular pizza place that serves up creative and delicious slices with unique toppings like black garlic molasses, Ezzo beef pepperoni, and goat cheese. They also offer housemade meats like jalapeno beef sausage and porchetta. In addition to their tasty food, they have 12 beers on tap as well as sangria and rosé for customers to enjoy with their slices.
(343)

Recent social media posts

06/02/2026

Meat lovers, this one’s calling your name. Loaded with grande mozzarella, sausage, pepperoni, applewood bacon, garlic, and our signature tomato sauce. The Carne Pizza brings all the savory goodness in every slice.

05/31/2026

Your slice is waiting. Grab yours today.

05/29/2026

Thank you, , for naming us no. 13 on the 50 Top Pizza Slice USA 2026 list! We are honored to be among such great company. Congrats to all the winners!

Photo 1: 50 Top Pizza
Photo 2 & 3: .palatepixels

05/27/2026

We know you’re hungry. From New York-style pizza to cheese curds, truffle parmesan fries, garlic knots, and more... this is your sign to stop by and order all the good stuff.

05/25/2026

Whatever the situation, our New York-style pizza is the always a great choice.

05/23/2026

So, what’s your vision for this room? Um, to fill it.

05/21/2026

Tossing dough like it’s a sport. Fresh pizza starts with the perfect stretch, the right shape, and a little bit of showmanship.

05/19/2026

An influencer said they charge $3000 for a post so we’re going to stand here with our New York-style pizza to see if that works.

05/17/2026

How to successfully kidnap me.

05/15/2026

Dough in progress for Sicilian-style Squares. Available after 4PM on Fri & Sat.

05/13/2026

Big slices, thin crust, Chicago address. We’re bringing New York-style pizza to Chicago with big slices, crispy crust, and that perfect foldable bite.

05/11/2026

Mushroom lovers, this one’s for you. The Quattro Funghi Truffle Pizza is loaded with rich, earthy mushroom flavor and finished with that irresistible truffle touch. A must-try for anyone who loves a savory, indulgent slice.

05/09/2026

Treat Mom to something warm, cheesy, and made with love. Good pizza, a welcoming atmosphere, and time spent together... everything Mom deserves this Mother’s Day. Join us at Jimmy’s Pizza and make it a meal to remember.

05/07/2026

She’s simple, but she’s the main character. A fresh-out-the-oven Margherita with thin crust, melty cheese, bright tomato sauce, and basil doing exactly what basil needs to do. Classic, but never boring.

05/05/2026

Oh, I’ve been waiting for this… and yes, it’s everything. A hot New York-style slice with crispy crust, cheesy goodness, and the kind of bite that makes the wait feel worth it.

05/03/2026

Which New York-style pizza are you going for?

05/01/2026

Basic human needs:

1. Air
2. Water
3. New York-style Pizza

04/29/2026

A little cheesy, a little saucy, a lot delicious. These Garlic Knots come topped with imported Parmesan and fresh basil, with marinara on the side for the perfect finishing touch.

04/27/2026

Pizza is important for survival. Dinosaurs didn’t have pizza and look what happened to them.

04/25/2026

Weekend plans? Follow the sizzle. Our Sicilian-style Squares is serving crispy, airy, cheesy perfection with that sizzle you can practically taste. Available every Friday and Saturday after 4PM.

04/23/2026

Hold it. Fold it. Devour it. Thin crust, melty cheese, and that classic hold-and-fold moment that makes every bite better.

04/21/2026

When someone says they don’t like New York-style pizza.

04/19/2026

Straight from the oven, straight to the table. Bubbling cheese, a crisp golden bottom, and a classic New York-style crust that folds like a dream. Hot, cheesy, and exactly what you want.

04/17/2026

Personality test. What’s your next bite? There’s definitely only one right answer.

04/15/2026

The slice says New York. The location says Chicago. No plane ticket needed. Jimmy’s Pizza Cafe is bringing that classic New York slice energy straight to Chicago.

Address

2434 W Montrose Avenue
Chicago, IL
60618

To reach the location on W Montrose Avenue in Chicago, one can take public transportation by heading to the nearest bus stop or train station and taking a route that passes through the area. Alternatively, if you prefer to drive there, you can park at any available parking spot nearby and walk to the location.

Opening Hours

Monday	5pm - 9pm
Tuesday	9am - 9pm
Wednesday	9am - 9pm
Thursday	9am - 9pm
Friday	9am - 10pm
Saturday	9am - 10pm
Sunday	9am - 9pm

Telephone

+17732936992

Website

http://jimmyspizzacafe.weborder.net/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Jimmys Pizza Cafe posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

What people say

If you're looking for a pizza place that offers unique and delicious toppings, look no further than Jimmys Pizza Cafe on W Montrose Avenue. Their social media posts showcase mouth-watering options like black garlic molasses, Ezzo beef pepperoni, goat cheese, black garlic cloves, black olive pate, fresh mozz, whole milk mozz, artichoke, red onion, mushroom, parmesan reggiano, fresh basil and more. They even have non-pizza options like housemade bulgogi with hot honey gochujang glaze and spicy crab with Old Bay Sriracha lime aioli.

But it's not just the toppings that make Jimmys Pizza Cafe stand out. They also offer 12 different beers on tap along with sangria and rosé to pair perfectly with your slices. And if you need a caffeine fix after indulging in their delicious pies, they even offer FREE cold brew coffee and mate.

Overall, Jimmys Pizza Cafe is a must-visit for anyone in the Chicago area who loves unique and tasty pizza options paired with great drinks.

Claim ownership or report listing